Academic integrity is an important pillar of higher education. A student’s earnest and transparent conduct in the course of their studies, as laid out/defined by their educational institution, ensures that the student’s work and effort at school remain credible. However, students can run afoul of rules that are meant to uphold standards of academic conduct, sometimes unknowingly, and thus face allegations of violating academic integrity.

If this ever happens, it is unpleasant and worrisome, both for the student and for those holding the student accountable. It makes for a serious situation that bears careful navigation, clarification and honesty from the student and their educational institution.

It’s important to keep in mind that an allegation against a student’s academic integrity is not a charge, and as such should not be considered a final verdict on their conduct, especially not by the student themselves.

So, when contending with an allegation of lack of academic integrity, what should a student do? Is there anything that the student needs to review or consider? Are their only options to accept or to deny?

The brief answer is: before a student even tries to confess or refute allegations of academic misconduct, they should:

  1. Make sure to know exactly what they stand accused of by their educational institution;
  2. Find out what evidence the educational institution has to support their allegation;
  3. Know the immediate next steps in either case (i.e. admission or denial of fault by the student); and,
  4. Find out how long they (i.e. the student) have to provide a response to the allegation(s) against them.

If a student stands accused of academic misconduct but does not have all of the information listed above, they should not respond to allegations at all; instead, they should do the necessary due diligence to first find out the above information.

It should be noted that doing this is not easy or straightforward. Students who are accused of academic misconduct in the case of, for example, an online exam that was flagged for cheating, are likely to feel an immense amount of stress. Seeing an accusation leveled against you and then being provided an online form through which to respond to those allegations can put undue pressure on the student to act quickly, perhaps to their own detriment!

While that instinct to respond fast, so that the issue can “go away”, is understandable, it is also how, ultimately, students can end up confessing things they don’t fully understand; or, they end up denying an accusation without knowing what a refutation can set in motion.

This article provides a handy outline of what a student should review before responding to allegations. It is important to note that procedural rules can be different for each educational institution; the information that follows should, therefore, be treated as general information and not legal advice.

What is the school alleging?

The first order of business is to for the student to start with the notice of accusation itself from the school. This should be read carefully and thoroughly, with an eye for specifics:

  • In the case of an exam marked for cheating: which exam was flagged, for which course and on what date?
  • Details of the exact conduct that the school says occurred (for example, leaving the camera view, using another program on the computer during an online exam, sharing answers, etc.)
  • The policy section cited as having been violated by the school

In addition to the above, students should also make sure to check the wording of these notices. The exact words and verbiage used in a written notice are crucial, as they ultimately serve the basis of the student’s defense, because it is this wording that has to be refuted: a flagged online exam and a formal charge are different things.

Proctoring tools used by schools flag behavior that the tools consider unusual, like a student looking away from their screen or a window opening in the background on the student’s computer/device on which the exam was being taken. A flagged behavior is an automated signal by a tool, and thus not the final word, which would be the school stating that the student violated a specific rule.

Some educational institutions might not distinguish between the two, so students should always attempt to diligently work out what they actually received: a formal charge, or an automated flag that could be clarified.

Lastly, claims about camera engagement, background software, or network activity are often stated in broad terms, like “suspicious activity detected;” this phrase doesn’t say anything about what the student is alleged to have done. So, if a school’s written notice is vague, that should be noted, because it can be brought up later.

What evidence does the school have for the alleged misconduct?

When considering the question of evidence, care should be taken to note whether a student’s school has provided, in writing, the full evidence or a summary of the evidence; both are distinct things.

If the student has been sent a full proctoring report by the school, the student should go through the report carefully, scanning every line. The student should note the description(s) of what the proctoring software observed whether there are any timestamps provided in the report, and/or if there are any screenshots or video clips. Once this is done, the information in the school’s written notice can reliably be sorted into one of the following two categories:

  • What the full evidence shows directly. For example: “A second browser tab was open at 2:14 p.m.”
  • What the school inferred from the evidence. For example: “The student was looking up answers.”

There is a very important and meaningful difference between the above two groups. For example, it is easy to prove/demonstrate that a student had a second tab open during a proctored online exam; but why the tab was open is not easily proven, thereby making any inference an unproven conclusion.

This also applies to a student not looking directly at their screen during the exam, which are flags that are often enough thrown up by proctoring software in cases where, for example, a student read a question aloud, was thinking whilst looking up at the ceiling, briefly looked away to see where a noise in the room came from or even just scribbled something on a piece of paper in front of them to process/think.

In the event that the student does not understand the activity report from the proctoring software, they should say so plainly and make a list of questions to ask the school. An example of such a question can be: “What program does the report say was running? Does it show I used it, or only that it was open?”

The student can, and in fact ideally should, also ask the school for the full record from the proctoring exam. Not only is this ethical obligation for the school, they are also obligated under law, as per the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA); according to FEPRA, students at schools that receive federal education funding generally have the right to inspect and review their education records. Whether a particular proctoring file counts as part of that record is something that can be taken up by any student with their school.

What does a confession or refutation mean under the school’s process?

Whether a student can “admit” or “deny” alleged misconduct may sound simple, but each of the two options one triggers a different next step at different educational institutions. Students should find the relevant policies at their school and read the response form before they select anything.

Here’s what to look for:

Question Why you need the answer
What happens if I admit? Some schools move straight to a sanction with no further review.
What happens if I deny? This often leads to a hearing or a review panel, but not always.
Can I change my answer later? Many schools treat the first response as final. Some don’t.
What are the stated consequences? Look for ranges: a zero on the exam, a failing grade, suspension, or a notation on your record.
Has a decision already been made? If a grade has already changed, the process may be further along than the form suggests.

The last row is especially important, as some students are asked to respond to an allegation after a grade penalty has already been applied by their school, even at the stage where misconduct stands alleged. This inevitably affects what the accused student is really choosing when deciding between “admit” or “deny.”

If an educational institution’s formal policies do not provide unambiguous answers to any of the above questions, students should ask these questions from their school and obtain a response; both should be in writing.

What information can the student verify independently?

During this process, the student should make sure to collect all of the information that they are entitled to and which they need in order to build their case, which will inevitably be put up against the educational institution’s account of what supposedly happened. This has to be done by the student before they respond to their school’s written notice that lays out the accusations against the student.

To begin with, in the case of a flagged online exam, the student should immediately write down what they recall about that exam, in their own words; details that are important are:

  • Where the exam was taken by the student (i.e. their dorm room, a library, etc.) and what was in the room/space;
  • What was open on the student’s computer/device, whether any non-exam-related programs were running in the background (e.g. messaging apps, screen-sharing tools, cloud backups, VPNs, etc.), and why;
  • Whether the student’s internet connection was dropped/interrupted during the exam, or if the exam proctoring software froze/malfunctioned;
  • Anything that interrupted the student, the nature of the interruption and its estimated duration, per the student’s memory.

Once all of this has been written down by the student, it should be organized into a coherent, written narrative, which should then be preserve by the student. The student should also keep the following as documentation for their case:

  • The original notice of allegation from their school;
  • Every email/communication with their instructor(s) or the integrity office of their educational institution;
  • The instructions for the exam, and the syllabus language on testing rules.

In addition to the above, students should take screenshots of anything that might change or disappear, like a student portal message. If a student has any programs on their computer that usually run on startup, these programs and their startup activity should also be noted. Ideally, the student should keep two lists:

  1. A list of things that the student is sure of and can support with a document or a record of their own.
  2. A list of things that the student thinks happened but cannot confirm.

When and how must the student respond?

The deadline for the student to respond to the school’s allegation is usually stated clearly, often in bold text, towards the beginning or even at the very end of the school’s written notice. The student should note this date and write it somewhere they can see it, such as a post-it note stuck to their desk. After that, the student should confirm how they are supposed to respond, i.e. via an online form, an email to a specific office, a signed document, or a meeting.

Following the above, the student should make note of what comes after an admission or denial. If the student denies the allegation, when would a hearing be scheduled, and how will they be told? Some schools send notices by email only, which means a missed message can mean a missed hearing.

At any rate, if something in the notice or the procedure is unclear, the student should plainly ask the school to clarify. This should be done in writing so that the student has a record. If the student needs more time, they should request an extension in writing and should absolutely not assume they have gotten an extension one until the school confirms in writing.

Conclusion: what should a student be able to say before they respond to their school’s allegation notice

In short, if a student is accused by their school of academic misconduct, they should be able to state the following without guessing, before they respond to the school’s allegations:

  1. The specific conduct the student is accused of;
  2. The evidence that the school is relying on;
  3. What admitting and denying each lead to;
  4. The deadline and the next step in the process;

If you’re facing an academic integrity allegation and want someone to look at the notice and the process with you, K Altman Law’s student defense team can help you understand where you stand. Call us, send an email, or fill out the intake form through Contact Us, and we’ll talk through your situation.