Don’t accept the repeat until the program explains in writing which rule requires a full semester and why the missing clinical hours can’t be made up on their own. If the school can’t name a rule or consider an exception, request a formal review before the appeal deadline.

Imagine you’re a nursing student, and you’re at the end of your semester. You’ve finished all of your coursework, taken your end-of-term exams, and passed all of them. You are now thinking of taking a well-deserved break and looking forward to your next semester.

Then, seemingly out of nowhere, the nursing program in which you’re enrolled says you have to repeat the whole semester; the same semester that you just concluded! You’re confused, but also very stressed because repeating an entire semester means paying tuition again for a semester that you thought was behind you, a graduation date that gets pushed further, and maybe even a delay in sitting for the National Council Licensure Examination for Registered Nurses (NCLEX-RN).

Given how stressful this situation can be, most students tend to react to it in one of two ways:

  1. Some students simply accept their nursing program’s decision because it came from the program itself; they may feel they have no recourse.
  2. Other students might push back immediately, but they might not know the underlying rules governing their nursing program’s decision, or at least how those rules are worded.

In either case, students unfortunately miss the step that tends to work in their favor: asking the nursing program specific questions and getting the answers in writing.

This article is meant to be a guide for students on what those questions can be, what the nursing program’s answers to those questions can tell you, and also which alternative courses of action students should consider raising. Please note that this is general information and not legal advice. Every program and every state board of nursing likely works differently.

What Should a Student Ask When a Program Requires a Full Semester Repeat for Missing Clinical Hours?

For any student staring down the possibility of a repeated semester, the first order of business is to try to find out why exactly their nursing program is making this decision.

If a student missed clinical hours, they can do this with four questions. The student should ideally send these questions in one email or written message to their course coordinator or program director. Communicating this way results in dated answers provided to the student in writing. This is preferable because written material can be cited later, whereas, say, a hallway conversation cannot.

Why Is an Entire Semester Required Instead of Completing Only the Outstanding Clinical Hours?

This first question should just be asked very plainly. By doing so, the student prompts program faculty to elaborate or provide an official reason in their specific case, the decision was made to repeat an entire semester. Broad statements like “That’s our policy” are not a valid reason, after all.

The nursing program’s answer can then be thoroughly considered, without the student having to guess the reason. Answers to this sort of question usually fall into three broad groups:

  1. The clinical and classroom parts are graded as one course;
  2. The program cannot schedule partial clinical placements; or
  3. A rule from outside the school requires it.

Each of the potential reasons above affects the next step the student should take.

Which Specific Academic or Clinical Requirements Remain Incomplete?

The purpose of asking this question is for the student to get a full list of requirements, with clearly stated numbers.

How many clinical hours are outstanding, and how many are required? Which skills checkoffs or competencies, if any, are not signed off? Which of the student’s exams and assignments are finished and passed?

Broad, incomplete statements from the nursing program (e.g., “You missed clinical”) are insufficient and should not be accepted. On the other hand, statements with concrete details and clear numbers (e.g., “You have 24 of 120 hours outstanding and every competency is signed off”) tell the student exactly what is left. From there, the student can begin to determine whether a repeated semester is a proportionate fix for the issue at hand.

What Written Policy Establishes the Full-Semester Repeat Requirement?

The next question should be about the exact policy the nursing program is invoking. The student should ask for the policy title, the section of the handbook it is in, and the edition of the handbook in effect when the student enrolled (or when the absences occurred).

The purpose is to review the policy’s language and determine whether the nursing program’s application is accurate or open to challenge. If nobody can point the student to a written policy, that is also an answer in itself.

Additionally, handbooks change from year to year, sometimes even between semesters; therefore, it is important to ask exactly which version of the handbook is being followed. If the semester repeat rule was added in a newer edition than the one the student was given at enrollment, that is an issue worth raising.

Who Has the Authority to Approve an Alternative Completion Arrangement?

The last of the four initial questions is meant to establish a clear picture of how the student can find recourse. By asking who has decision-making authority in this situation, the student can determine to whom to appeal. This is because the person communicating the need for a semester repeat is often not the same person who can change the outcome of the student’s situation.

Program policies are usually enforced by instructors, with some exceptions that typically go straight to a program director, a progression committee, or an associate dean. The student should ask for the name and title of the person who can approve an alternative remedy for the student’s predicament, and ask how to submit a request.

How Can the Student Verify Whether the Semester Repeat Is Academically Required?

Program rules are officially codified in handbooks, which are made readily available to all students. For this reason, any student can easily go over any area of school policy that governs their studies.

In the case of a semester repeat, students can review much of the official school policy before they even ask anyone in the faculty or administration. This is also why, as outlined in the previous section, students should ask the program staff which specific part of which edition of the handbook is being enacted.

Students can independently pull their syllabus, transcript, their clinical attendance records, and also their clinical evaluations, after which they can go over official written policy themselves to check their data against it.

Compare Completed Coursework with Outstanding Clinical Requirements

As a first step, nursing students should line up what parts of their semester coursework and practical clinical work have been completed; this should be compared to what is required, thus outlining how much of the coursework or clinical requirements still remains.

If the student’s classroom grades are passing and the gap is a defined number of clinical hours, this can be a documented basis for the student to ask why the remedy for their shortfall is something as disproportionate as repeating an entire semester.

Determine How Many More Clinical Hours Are Still Needed

Following from the above, students should count for themselves the number of clinical hours they have actually completed, using their own records. They should then compare this count with the nursing program’s count. The sign-in sheets and preceptor logs the nursing program uses may contain errors. Students should try to identify and resolve any differences before accepting the program’s number.

Review Whether Clinical and Classroom Components Are Separately Assessed

Every nursing student receives a syllabus that states the grading standards and passing criteria for their courses. Broadly, these can be separated into:

The Number of Completed Didactic Courses and Earned Academic Credits

Within this context, “didactic” refers to classroom instruction. Students should check whether the classroom portion of each course on the transcript has its own course number, credits, and grade. If it does, it is a completed course on the record.

The Number of Outstanding Clinical Competencies and Supervised Training Hours

Next, check whether the clinical component has its own course number or is incorporated into the classroom course as a pass/fail component. The things to note here are the number of hours and the competencies that the clinical component requires, as these define what is actually outstanding.

Check Whether Previously Completed Academic and Clinical Work Can Be Factored In

One thing students should ask their nursing program, in writing, is whether passed exams, graded assignments, and clinical hours they have already completed carry over to a repeat semester or a make-up plan. Different schools have different policies, and some programs even set a time limit on how long completed work stays valid. However, this is still a useful thing to ask.

What Policies or Regulatory Requirements Could Explain the Full-Semester Repeat?

At this point, the student’s goal will be to clearly and definitively determine why their nursing program has deemed a repeat semester necessary, given all the information they have collected so far.

Students are usually told that something is “required” of them (e.g., to successfully pass a course, an assignment, etc.); but often enough, students are not told by whom it is required. In the case of a semester repeat, sorting out the “who” is the next step and also the most useful work in this section.

There are broadly four ways a repeat semester for a nursing student can end up being required: the nursing program’s own policy requires it; a state board rule mandates it; an accreditation standard says it is necessary; or a contract with a clinical site stipulates it. A nursing program itself can sometimes adjust its own policy, but a state board rule is not for the school to waive.

Students can review the requirements and map out the “who”, as done in the example table below.

Source of the requirement Who sets it Can the program adjust it?
Handbook policy. The school. Often, through an exception process.
State board of nursing rule. The state board. Generally, no.
Accreditation standard. The accrediting body. Generally, no.
Clinical site agreement. The school and the healthcare facility. Sometimes, if the site agrees.

Review the Nursing Program’s Course Repetition and Progression Policies

At this point, the student should consult their nursing student handbook and thoroughly review the policies codified within. Nursing programs often have stricter progression rules than rules any other program at the school.

Students should review the exact wording in sections on progression, course repetition, clinical attendance, clinical make-up, and incomplete grades. Phrases like “unsatisfactory clinical performance”, “clinical failure” and “must repeat the course” carry specific consequences.

Pay special attention to how the nursing student handbook classifies missed clinical hours. Many handbooks treat the clinical as a pass or fail component, so failing it means failing the whole course even when a student’s exam average is strong. So, if a student’s missed clinical hours were labeled a clinical failure, a full semester repeat may follow automatically from that label.

However, if the clinical component was labeled as an excused absence or an incomplete requirement, a different path could possibly apply, such as make-up hours or an incomplete grade for the course in question. Students should ask how the program classified their clinical component and on what basis. If the absences came from illness, a family emergency, or another documented reason, the student should ask whether the handbook’s excused-absence provisions apply to the absences.

Clinical hours are usually built into credits as well. For example, one university nursing school publishes a formula for prelicensure clinical hours: clinical credits, times a ratio, times 15 weeks. A two-credit clinical at a 1:3 ratio equals 90 hours. When hours are tied to credits this way, a nursing program may say partial credit isn’t possible. This could explain any resistance from the nursing program to a partial fix. However, on its own, it doesn’t explain why a student who has already passed classroom work needs to repeat it.

Determine Whether the Clinical Component Is Inseparable from the Course Grade

Programs generally use one of two structures:

  • A combined course: One course number and one grade, whereby the syllabus requires that both the classroom and clinical parts be passed and missing either part requires repeating the course.
  • Separate linked courses: A theory course and a clinical course, each with its own grade. This is also referred to as a “corequisite”, i.e., a course the student must take in the same term as another. In this case, only the incomplete course should need to be repeated. However, some programs require both to be retaken together.

An example of a direct question that students can ask here is: “Is clinical a separate course on my transcript?” If it is treated as a separate course, and the nursing program still requires the student to repeat the theory course, the student should ask for the policy that links the theory and clinical course. Some programs have a legitimate stated reason as to why this is done (e.g., content designed to run in parallel). This reason can only be evaluated once the nursing program provides it in writing.

Ask Whether Applicable Nursing Board or Accreditation Requirements Mandate Repetition

It is not uncommon for nursing program staff to simply point to the applicable state board of nursing or accreditor. In such cases, students should ask staff what those bodies actually say on the matter at hand.

Distinguish External Regulatory Requirements from Institutional Policies

State boards: Each state board approves nursing programs and sets minimum standards for the programs. Different states may set different minimums for clinical hours, so students should check their own state’s current rule. In some cases, rules and guidance focus on what a program must provide overall and little to nothing on how a student can make up a shortfall. This is another reason that students should refer to their state board for their specific rules.

For example, in a 2020 letter to program directors, the Pennsylvania State Board of Nursing (PSBN) noted that its registered nurse (RN) program regulations do not prescribe a specific number of clinical or didactic hours. However, the letter also noted that the PSBN’s practical nursing regulations require 60 percent clinical hours.

Simulation: Many boards allow some clinical hours to be replaced with simulation exercises. This suggests that the “hours must be earned at a hospital” norm is not always an outside requirement. More details are in the alternatives section below.

Accreditors: The Commission on Collegiate Nursing Education (CCNE) publishes accreditation standards that call for academic policies that are written, communicated to students, and implemented consistently. Nothing within these standards appears to prescribe a full-semester repeat for missed clinical hours. CCNE has revised its standards in recent years, so it is important that students check the version currently in effect, and check whether their program is accredited by CCNE or another body.

Clinical site agreements: Hospitals and clinics sign contracts with schools that can limit how many students attend, when they can attend, and under whose supervision they attend the medical facilities for their clinical hours. This non-regulatory factor can be a real constraint on scheduling for nursing students.

Request Identification of the Specific Applicable Rule

Put plainly, students should ask their nursing program to identify and name the rule that is being applied in their case. This can ultimately also reveal the source entity of the rule and/or constraint. An example of how students can word their query to program staff is:

“Kindly identify the specific state board regulation, accreditation standard, or handbook policy that requires me to repeat a full semester instead of completing just my remaining clinical hours. Please also include the citation or handbook page number for my own reference.”

If, in response to this query, nursing program staff cite a board rule, the student should look it up on the board’s website. If program staff respond by saying “the board requires it” but do not cite any specific rule or policy, students should ask program staff to confirm directly with the board. Students can also simply ask the board’s education staff how the rule applies to them.

Examine Whether Exceptions or Individualized Completion Plans Are Permitted

A targeted search of the nursing student handbook can be useful. If phrases such as “at the discretion of the program director”, “exceptions may be granted”, “extenuating circumstances”, and “individual remediation plan” appear in the handbook, exceptions may exist in writing, and the student can ask for them to be considered.

In addition, it is vital that the student ask whether the program has approved alternatives in similar situations. Although the school will not share other students’ details because of privacy law, it can nevertheless say whether the option exists and also outline how it works. Because accreditation standards require consistent policy application to all students, a program that offers make-up hours to one student but denies them to another must be able to explain the difference in its approach.

What Alternatives to Repeating an Entire Semester Should the Student Explore?

Another important line of inquiry for a student facing a repeat semester is whether there are any alternative remediations. It should be noted that the existence of alternatives depends entirely on the nursing program’s policy, the state board, and the program’s clinical partners.

Nevertheless, students should explore their options and present them as proposals to the relevant authority. Specific proposals can get better responses than simply asking program staff, “Is there anything else I can do?”

Completing the Missing Clinical Hours Through Additional Scheduled Rotations

Many nursing programs run clinical hours in groups with a fixed number of seats. Students should ask whether they can add their missing hours to another group in the same semester or add extra days at the end of the semester. Factors that might prevent either option usually include available seats, instructor availability, and approval from the clinical site, which is a contractual partner of the school in most cases.

The way to ask this is to make it concrete; an example could be: “I need 24 more hours of clinical. Can I please join the Thursday group for three additional shifts of eight hours?” This is a straightforward ask that any program can answer with a “yes” or “no” in an email.

Enrolling in an Approved Clinical Make-Up or Independent Clinical Component

When looking for alternatives, students should explore ways to fulfill their clinical hours through other approved methods. Some nursing programs offer make-up days, skills lab hours, simulation, or preceptor-supervised hours. A preceptor is a practicing nurse who supervises a student in a clinical setting. All of these can be viable options.

Simulation is the alternative with the most evidence of benefit. The National Council of State Boards of Nursing (NCSBN) ran a randomized national study across ten programs and found that replacing up to half of traditional clinical hours with high-quality simulation produced comparable learning outcomes under the study’s conditions. NCSBN’s simulation guidelines note that every program in that study required at least 600 clinical hours.

However, state boards set their own limits. For example, the Idaho Board of Nursing allows up to 50 percent of clinical experience in each course to be replaced by simulation. Other states set different caps. What students need to ask is:

  • Does the nursing program offer any make-up options, and are simulation hours one such option?
  • Does the state board permit simulation to count toward missing clinical hours?
  • Who supervises the make-up, whether in clinical hours or in simulation, and how are the hours documented?

Completing Outstanding Clinical Requirements During a Subsequent Term

Another option students should explore is whether they can make up missing clinical hours in a future term. More specifically, students should ask their program staff about how they handle an incomplete grade or a deferred completion. If viable, this option can allow a student to complete the hours without repeating the course.

Students should also ask about the deadline to apply for this option, any fees, and whether they can start the next level of courses while the hours are pending. Next-level courses often list the earlier course as a prerequisite, so this question determines whether the student’s timeline moves at all.

Seeking an Alternative Approved Clinical Placement

It is worth considering moving to a different unit, shift, or facility, including evenings or weekends, provided they are available. Since programs only place their students at sites they have agreements with, and a new site usually requires some onboarding (e.g., background checks, immunization records, orientation, etc.), students should ask how long the onboarding takes and proactively offer to finish the paperwork in advance.

If a student’s original absences were tied to a placement problem, such as a canceled rotation or a conflict with an assigned site, they should state that directly.

Requesting an Individualized Academic Completion Plan

Some nursing programs may offer individualized remediation. Students should ask their program, in writing, if it is open to something that is just short of a full semester repeat. If the program can offer such an individualized plan in writing, it should list the remaining hours or competencies that the student needs, the dates, who supervises and verifies them, and what happens on completion, including when the student progresses or graduates.

If the nursing program agrees to provide such a plan in writing, students should ask that the program director or a designee sign it. This way, the student has a clear path forward, while both the student and the program have a written record of the agreement.

What Academic and Financial Consequences Should the Student Clarify?

Throughout this process of finding a way forward in the case of a semester repeat, students will invariably find that there are a number of avenues they can pursue. Whichever path they choose, it is important that they get written answers to the following five questions before committing to anything.

1. “Will Previously Earned Course Credits Remain Valid?”

As covered earlier in this guide, this question matters because it can determine how much needs to be repeated during a repeat semester. Students should ask whether earned credits stay on their transcript and count toward their degree, and whether those credits have an expiration window.

2. “Must the Student Repeat Exams, Assignments, or Previously Passed Coursework?”

Following from the previous question, students should narrow their inquiry further to ask whether grades on passed exams and assignments carry over or must be redone. If the answer is that everything is redone, students should ask which policy mandates this and then independently check the policy and its verbiage, for good measure.

3. “How Will the Semester Repeat Affect GPA and Academic Standing?”

Ask whether the original grade is replaced or both attempts are counted in their grade point average (GPA). Ask whether a repeat affects probation status, progression standing, or eligibility for scholarships and honors.

4. “What Additional Tuition, Fees, and Financial Aid Consequences Could Apply?”

A repeat semester likely has financial implications. For this reason, any student facing a repeat semester should ask the bursar and the financial aid office separately, in writing, what the repeat term will cost and whether any aid covers it. The student should ask whether the repeat affects satisfactory academic progress, the standard many schools use to decide whether a student remains eligible for financial aid.

5. “How Will the Requirement Affect the Expected Graduation Date?”

Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, the student should get their new expected completion date on the record. A nursing student’s application to take the NCLEX-RN generally follows their program’s verification that the student has completed the program itself. Needless to say, a semester-long delay in graduation moves the whole timeline.

How Can the Student Request Review of the Full-Semester Repeat Requirement?

Students should not assume they cannot appeal the decision to repeat a semester. In most cases, they should write a calm, specific email to their program asking for a review of the decision. Student handbooks often include information on appeal windows, which are usually quite short; students should find the deadline before they do anything else.

Ask for a Written Explanation of Why a Clinical-Hours-Only Solution Is Unavailable

Once again, the way to do this is to write a calm, professional, and plainly worded email; for example: “I would like to ask that you please explain why I cannot complete only the outstanding clinical hours. Please also identify the policy or rule that requires the full-semester repeat.”

Asking this way can prompt a specific, detailed written response from the program, which the student can then respond to and act on.

Present Documentation of Completed Coursework and Verified Clinical Hours

In making their case, students should make a file that includes their transcript, syllabus, attendance logs, clinical evaluations, and the emails between them and their nursing program. Students have the right to the records their school keeps about them and, under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), can inspect their education records within 45 days of a written request. Students can also ask their school to correct records if they believe that the records are inaccurate.

Because the 45-day timeline can outlast an appeal deadline, students should request their records early and tell the school the request is time-sensitive.

Identify the Appropriate Academic Appeal or Exception-Request Procedure

The student handbook may outline an academic appeal process, a grievance process, and even an exception process.

An exception request asks the program to waive a policy for the student, provided certain conditions are met. The purpose of an appeal is to argue that the relevant policy was applied incorrectly; both of these are different things, but may nevertheless need to be filed at the same time. Students should note who decides each one, what the deadlines are, and what they are allowed to submit in support of either request.

Request a Written Comparison of Available Completion Options

It can help to ask the nursing program to list each available completion option in one document, with its cost, timeline, and requirements. For options that are not available, students should ask their program why. If the program declines to provide this, a written refusal still records its position.

Seek a Final Written Decision Addressing Both Academic Requirements and Graduation Timing

In the end, students should ask for a written decision that clearly states what they need to complete, which policy requires it, the expected graduation date, and the student’s rights, to the next level of appeal. Students should keep a copy of this and should absolutely not rely on any verbal confirmations.

When to Get Help Before You Respond

If you have a deadline to accept a plan or file an appeal, or if the answers you are getting are vague or contradict each other, it helps to have someone review the situation before you reply. The same is true if the program cites a rule it will not show you.

K Altman Law helps students work through disputes with their schools, including progression and dismissal problems. You do not need your documents organized before you reach out. Use the Contact Us page, send an email, or fill out the intake form, and someone can talk you through where you stand and what your options are.